When Protection Becomes Control


The Dangerous War on Adult Creators
Why the UK's latest attacks on adult content threaten far more than pornography.
At what point does protecting people become controlling them? That's the question I've been asking myself as I watch what's happening in the United Kingdom. In November 2026, the UK introduced new criminal restrictions on certain categories of pornography, including depictions of strangulation, certain incest scenarios, and adults roleplaying as children under 16. Just days later, a group of British parliamentarians called for something even more alarming: criminalizing commercial live camming and introducing new offences targeting what they call "e-pimping." And while that proposed camming ban has not become law, the fact that it's being seriously recommended should concern anyone who values bodily autonomy, freedom of expression, privacy, or the right to earn a living...because this conversation isn't just about pornography.... It's about who gets to decide what consenting adults are allowed to do with their own bodies.
I Am a Sex Worker, Not a Victim by Default
I've spent over fourteen years working in the adult entertainment industry. I've built a business, developed relationships with customers, learned new skills, and made my own decisions about the content I create and the people I choose to work with. That doesn't mean every experience has been perfect. It doesn't mean exploitation doesn't exist in this industry. It absolutely does. But exploitation exists in countless industries. People are mistreated in hospitality, retail, agriculture, entertainment, and corporate workplaces. We recognize those problems as reasons to improve working conditions, strengthen protections, and hold abusive employers accountable. We don't respond by declaring that every person working in those industries must be rescued from their own employment. So why is sex work treated differently? Why is my ability to make informed decisions suddenly considered less legitimate because my work involves sexuality? There is an huge difference between someone being forced into sexual activity and someone choosing to create adult content.
When lawmakers refuse to acknowledge that distinction, they're not protecting people like me. They're speaking over us. We've Seen This Before: FOSTA and SESTA
In 2018, the United States passed FOSTA-SESTA, legislation intended to combat online sex trafficking by increasing legal liability for websites that facilitate prostitution or sex trafficking.
The intentions sounded noble, however the consequences for many independent sex workers were devastating. Websites shut down services, platforms restricted adult content, and sex workers reported losing access to advertising, income, client-screening tools, and online communities that helped keep them safe. Rather than eliminating exploitation, these laws created conditions that pushed some workers toward riskier situations.
That's why the UK's latest proposals worry me. We've already seen what happens when governments confuse consensual sex work with trafficking and treat censorship as a substitute for meaningful protection. We cannot keep repeating the same mistakes and pretending we're protecting people when we're actually removing their resources, independence, and ability to protect themselves. And we can't control consenting adults, because we don't like those things.
The Illusion of Protection
One of the most troubling aspects of the proposed UK camming ban is the language surrounding it. The report, titled Only Exploitation, raises concerns about coercion, privacy violations, financial exploitation, and abuse within the webcam industry. Those are serious concerns. They deserve serious solutions. But suggesting that the entire commercial camming industry should be prohibited because exploitation can occur within it is an extraordinary leap.
For many adult creators, online work offers something incredibly valuable: independence.
We can work from our own homes. Set boundaries. Decide when to log off. Refuse customers. Choose what we are comfortable performing. Avoid physical contact with clients altogether. That independence matters. For some people, online adult work is more accessible than conventional employment because of disability, caregiving responsibilities, scheduling limitations, or the need to work remotely. Taking away those options doesn't automatically create safer alternatives. It can create desperation. And desperation is exactly what exploitative people take advantage of. If governments genuinely want to reduce exploitation, they should be empowering independent workers, not removing their ability to work independently.
Who Decides What Is Acceptable?
Sexuality is deeply personal. Different people have different interests, fantasies, relationships, boundaries, and ways of expressing themselves. Something that seems unusual or uncomfortable to one person may be entirely ordinary to another. You do not have to enjoy someone's sexual preferences to respect their freedom. You do not have to watch pornography to believe adults should be allowed to create it. You do not have to support sex work as a personal career choice to believe sex workers deserve rights.
The moment we begin allowing governments to criminalize consensual adult expression simply because someone finds it morally objectionable, we enter dangerous territory.
Because who determines the standard? A politician? A religious institution? A regulatory agency? The loudest advocacy group? And what happens when that standard changes?
Personal discomfort should not automatically become public policy. The purpose of government should be to protect people from harm, not enforce one preferred vision of morality on everyone else.
The Internet Doesn't Stop at a Border
Another concern is how these laws affect creators who don't even live in the United Kingdom.
Adult entertainment is a global industry. A creator in Canada might have customers in London. A platform headquartered in one country might serve audiences across dozens of others. The Free Speech Coalition has warned that material accessible in the UK may create legal exposure, particularly for businesses publishing or storing content there. That means creators outside the UK may still face restrictions imposed by platforms trying to comply with British law. And that creates a ripple effect. A creator might lose access to British customers. A platform might remove entire content categories rather than risk penalties. Existing videos might disappear, even if everyone involved was an adult who willingly participated. For someone who earns their living through digital content, that isn't a minor inconvenience.
That can mean losing years of work, recurring income, and access to an audience they've spent years building. It also raises a much bigger question. Should one government's interpretation of acceptable adult sexuality effectively determine what creators in other countries are allowed to publish? I don't believe it should.
When Laws Make People Less Safe
Here's what worries me most... when legitimate platforms become too difficult or risky to operate, the demand for adult entertainment doesn't simply disappear. People look elsewhere. And when creators lose access to established platforms, payment systems, and public-facing businesses, some may feel pressured toward less regulated alternatives.
That can mean fewer safeguards, weaker complaint systems, more difficulty reporting abuse, and greater dependence on intermediaries who promise to keep their income flowing.
In other words, poorly designed protections can risk creating the very conditions they claim to prevent. Of course, not every online platform currently offers adequate protection. Some have failed performers terribly. That's an argument for stronger standards, not an automatic argument for prohibition. We should be demanding meaningful age verification, consent documentation, which is something I've personally fought for in a campaign prior to PornHubs age verification implementation. We should also be demanding transparent payment practices, accessible reporting systems, privacy protections, and serious consequences for coercion. We should be making it easier for workers to identify abuse, report offenders, and leave exploitative arrangements. We should be listening to the people doing the work. Because safety should never require silence. And protection should never mean stripping people of their choices.
Why Aren't We Listening to Sex Workers?
There is something SOOOO frustrating about watching people debate the future of your livelihood while treating your perspective as optional. Sex workers are often discussed as though we're a single, helpless population. We're not. We're parents, students, entrepreneurs, artists, disabled workers, caregivers, and people from every imaginable background. Some entered the industry because it offered financial opportunity. Others needed flexible employment. Some genuinely enjoy the work. Others have complicated relationships with it. All of those experiences deserve to be heard. And yes, that includes people who have experienced exploitation and want stronger intervention. Their voices matter too. But no single experience should erase everyone else's.
If lawmakers truly want to understand the adult industry, they need to speak to the people working in it, including independent creators, survivors, labour advocates, and people with opposing views. Not just organizations that have already decided what our lives should look like. You cannot claim to empower people while refusing to trust them with a voice in decisions about their own futures. likeeeee what year is it?
Freedom Isn't Only for People You Agree With
I think this is the part everyone should pay attention to, which I kind of bushed on earlier.. but, personal freedom isn't meaningful only when someone's choices resemble your own. It's meaningful when we defend people's rights to make lawful, consensual decisions that we might not personally make ourselves. You can dislike pornography and still oppose censorship. You can believe some sexual practices are dangerous and still question whether criminalizing depictions of them is the most effective response. You can condemn exploitation while defending independent adult workers. Those positions are not contradictory. They're what thoughtful, proportionate policy should look like. We need laws that distinguish exploitation from autonomy, abuse from consent, and actual harm from moral discomfort. Its like when church is crossed with law. Don't impose your idealization on me. No one is forcing you to watch the porn when you don't agree with it. And we need to be willing to ask whether criminalization genuinely solves the problems being used to justify it. Because banning something is easy. Demonstrating that the ban actually makes people safer is much harder, and they brush that part under the rug without actually following up on the real life consequences that sex workers who love their job end up being faced with etc. It has a complete ripple effect that no one seems to care about.
My Body. My Work. My Choice.
After fourteen years in this industry, one thing has become abundantly clear to me.
Sex workers do not need everyone to approve of what we do. We need the same respect for our autonomy, safety, labour, and human dignity that other workers deserve. We need protection from coercion, not protection from our own independence. We need meaningful privacy rights, not surveillance disguised as concern. We need governments willing to confront real exploitation without treating every consenting adult as a potential criminal or victim. And we need people to understand that defending the rights of adult creators isn't just about defending pornography. It's about defending the principle that adults should have a meaningful say over their own bodies, their expression, and their livelihoods.
The government has every reason to intervene when someone is being harmed, threatened, trafficked, or abused. But when informed, consenting adults are making choices that do not violate anyone else's rights, the burden should be on the government to justify interfering, not on those adults to justify their freedom. Because if the government can take away your choices in the name of protecting you, without listening to you or demonstrating that its intervention makes you safer, what kind of protection is that? And whose interests is it really serving?



Comments